1. Does the rent cover the costs?
Add up the mortgage payment, property taxes, insurance, a reserve for repairs and vacancies, and management if you will use a manager. Compare that with a realistic rent from comparable homes. If the rent comfortably covers everything, renting can build equity while someone else pays the mortgage. If it does not, you are paying to keep the house.
2. What is your mortgage rate?
Many owners locked in low mortgage rates. Selling gives that rate up for good, and buying again later may cost more each month. Renting the home out keeps the low-rate loan working for you. Check your mortgage terms and tell your lender if the home will no longer be your primary residence.
3. Taxes when you sell
If you lived in the home for at least two of the five years before selling, you may be able to exclude a large part of the gain from federal tax. Renting the home for several years can affect that, so the timing of a future sale matters. Michigan property taxes can also go up when a home stops being your principal residence. Talk to a tax professional about your numbers before deciding.
4. What does the home need?
A home that needs a new roof, furnace or kitchen may be easier to sell as is than to bring up to rental condition. On the other hand, updates that make a home rentable also help it hold its value for a future sale.
5. Your time and distance
Being a landlord means handling repair calls, late rent, turnovers and city rules. If you are moving away or simply do not want that work, a property manager can handle it, but that cost belongs in your numbers from step 1.
A simple way to decide
Get two numbers: a realistic sale price after selling costs, and a realistic monthly rent after all costs. Then ask whether keeping the home moves you closer to your goals than having the cash today. We are happy to provide the rent side of that comparison with a free rental analysis.
Sources
Want us to handle this for you?
Vilcasa manages rental homes across Wayne, Oakland and Washtenaw counties.